LiveAutomatic Newsletter

Subscribe now for LiveAutomatic exclusives!



Cat Genie review - Automatic litter box reviews PDF Print E-mail
For Pets
Written by Peter   
Friday, 16 May 2008 01:13

Cat GenieLittermaid

Cat Genie

Littermaid

RatingRatingRatingRatingRating

Rating: 5 out of 5

RatingRatingRatingRatingRating

Rating: 3 out of 5

Stupid cat. That's what I used to think when cleaning the litterbox and grumbling to myself about him prancing around like royalty while I clean up after his majesty. Of course, the simple solution of getting rid of the little bugger isn't really an option due to the wife's emotional attachment. So what's a guy to do?

 

Note: For an at-a-glance view of Litter Robot vs Cat Genie vs Littermaid vs Scoop Free click here.

 

My first attempt at solving the problem was to search for some sort of automatic litter box, insisting that someone has to have this figured out by now – I was right, but there are several options and you can only do so much reading about a cat litter box before you feel awkward and bored. I settled on the Littermaid box which essentially uses a rake to run across the litter, scooping up any cat droppings into a container which becomes air-tight after the rake goes back to its resting place.

There is a sensor to stop the rake in case the cat does something silly like jump in, and I figured that emptying the container once a week would surely be easier than each and every day as I did currently (ok, once every couple days, but it begins to stink after that.) After some mild threats about giving the cat away, I received wife approval for the expenditure and ordered it immediately...

The next week the package arrived at our doorstep and we rushed home from work to open it. Littermaid setup and readyWe paused momentarily to look at each other, slightly embarrassed at the fact that we were so excited about a litterbox, but didn't let that stop our fun. The package had 5 pieces, the bottom pan, the top motor and rake assembly, the 2 pieces of the airtight container (disposable btw, although you can just dump it out as I did) and a little carpeted ramp that the cat can walk up. The Littermaid runs on batteries or with a plug that it comes with, and although the battery compartment lid seemed a bit flimsy, it stayed on once I fumbled with it a bit.

 

 

Once filled with litter (clumping is required, so that the liquid can be scooped up as well) you just turn it on and walk away – or such is the theory. In practice, we found the Littermaid to be very sensitive to litter levels, and although there is a line on the inside for "maximum level" we generally found that a little below this line worked best. Too much litter and the rake has a hard time going back to its resting position, and ends up running back and forth constantly until you remove some litter. Apart from the litter-level issue, we found it worked quite well. With two cats, the container was filling up faster than I would've liked, so I created my own container by duct-taping two together and placing the litterbox on a small box to raise it up (necessary for the new taller container.) This worked, but was a bit of a pain to empty – a tradeoff for the ability to empty it less frequently I suppose.

 

We review the Littermaid in more depth if you're interested. Overall, the Littermaid was a step up – but it wasn't quite…perfect. After about a year, I began searching again, hoping that some brilliant engineers somewhere had created a design that was just that much better.

Sure enough, they had, and it was called the Cat Genie. I read about the concept, some cat genie reviews and was immediately impressed. The Cat Genie connects to your cold water tap, your drain (laundry room drain or toilet) and power so that it can completely handle the entire process.

Never touch the litterbox again! Wow. WOW.

 

CatGenie setup

The concept is that you have granules that are the same consistency as litter, but are permanent. The cat does his business, then at a time set by you the CatGenie begins to scoop out the solids (liquids drain immediately through drain holes at the bottom of the box, into a holding area until the cycle runs) and place them into what amounts to a blender hidden inside the main unit. Water mixed with scented 'SaniSolution' (the green item in the picture) is then run down the side of the bowl, while the bowl turns to ensure everything is washed down. The impeller in the back activates and liquefies all the cat poop before sending it down the drain (with any other liquids from the holding tank mentioned before). During this, the rake comes down, washes the granules and generally stirs things up (including washing the rake itself). Finally, once the final drain cycle occurs, a blow-dryer turns on and dries the granules, creating a perfect clean box for kitty. Absolutely amazing, both from an engineering perspective and from sheer joy of never touching the box again.

In my personal experience, the only snags we had were regarding the drain hose - it's pretty long, so making sure there aren't any sharp bends along the way (gradual corners are fine) and ensuring that it isn't pinched on the end. Once you tweak it a bit to ensure that the drain path is clear, everything else is hands-off. SaniSolution cartridges are good for 60 uses, so based on the recommended 'number of cycles per day = number of cats' formula, the SaniSolution will last two months with one cat, one month with two cats, and so on. SaniSolution is the only ongoing cost however, as the litter granules are permanent. As one reader pointed out, the $20/month that is saved by not purchasing litter results in the Cat Genie paying for itself in just over a year.

Amazingly, I have grown to like the little guy over the past 6 months – Having not touched his box during this time makes all the difference, although he still acts like he owns the place…For anyone who is considering purchasing an automatic litter box, I highly recommend the Cat Genie. These guys have the CatGenie at a better price than anyone else, and have incredibly fast shipping, even to Canada (we ordered from them with regular shipping and had it in a week).

 

For more photos of the Littermaid and Cat Genie, visit the photos section.

 

 

Related:

Other reviews of the Cat Genie
Other reviews of the Littermaid
Buy the Cat Genie
Buy the Littermaid
Find the Cat Genie on EbayFind the Littermaid on Ebay
Comments
Add New Search
+/-
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.
Sandra  - I need this!   |2008-05-21 20:09:35
I didn't know these existed - I am off to purchase one of these for our two
cats!
Kathy  - Litter cost   |2008-05-23 07:17:07
It seems like a lot of money, but when you consider not spending $20/month on
litter, it pays for itself in just over a year.
Peter   |2008-05-25 10:20:19
Good point Kathy! I've updated the article with this information - It may help
some people in their decisions.
Mike  - The Litter Robot   |2008-05-27 17:45:37
What I found out about the Cat Genie is that the money you save on litter gets
spent on sanitizer. If you run one cleaning cycle every 24 hours, you'll spend
at least $80. Letting the cat poop hang around for 24 hours before you run a
cleaning cycle sounds like it will smell up the house. With an automatic litter
box like the Litter Robot (www.Litter-Robot.com) the litter box goes through a
cleaning cycle 7 minutes after it is used by the cat. Sounds like a better
solution if you are concerned about odor.
Peter   |2008-05-27 18:45:25
Mike - I heavily researched all the options including the Litter Robot before
purchasing the Cat Genie. To address your points:
1 - The Sani Solution
cartridges last 60 cycles PER cartridge, so a three pack of cartridges ($38.99)
should last 6 months running the Cat Genie once per day. This is the ONLY cost
for the Cat Genie, whereas the Litter Robot still has the litter cost, which is
likely to be much more than the $6.50 per month that the Cat Genie's solution
costs.

2 - The Cat Genie actually disposes of the waste through your plumbing,
the Litter Robot does not. You still need to bag up and throw out the Litter
Robot's waste, and that is problematic for health reasons, and especially for
pregnant women - No such concern with the Cat Genie.

I don't have any
particular bias towards the Cat Genie other than it WORKS. We used the
LitterMaid for a year (which is very similar in concept to the Litter Robot -
both rake and store waste in a container) and while it made things easier, the
problem remained of tending to the stinky mess. You literally don't touch the
Cat Genie for months at a time, and THAT puts it very high in my books.

Hope
this helps!
J  - cat genie   |2008-07-01 21:29:33
I think people should stop and consider that the Cat Genie flushes waste that
could otherwise be composted. Hopefully people aren't that spoiled that they
can't deal with disposing of the waste in the receptacle of either the Litter
Robot or the Littermaid. Please think about our environment!
Jim  - cat genie   |2008-07-05 11:38:37
So so you all know, you should NEVER compost cat waste.... serious health issues
can arise from cat waste. It is best to go down the drain!
Just my 2 cents!
Amanda   |2008-07-20 15:02:35
NEVER NEVER compost cat litter!
Denise   |2009-02-28 23:21:03
NEVER compost cat waste! The only type of animals whose waste can be used as a
type of fertilizer are herbivores, not carnivores which cats most definitely
are.
Alex  - How many cycles per day?   |2008-07-15 13:25:34
This seems like a great idea but how often do you run a cycle with two cats?
Since I don't empty our normal box but once every two days I can't imagine
needing to cycle more than once a day but maybe I'm missing something?

Also,
the Cat Genie says that it comes with two boxes of their litter-like granules.
Why does it do that if they are not disposable, do you find yourself losing
granules? If so, that's another cost to consider.
Peter   |2008-07-15 14:01:23
Alex,

Your logic is solid - If you clean your current box once every couple
days, you could set it to once per day and be fine. You may find that since
it's completely automated and not a hassle like cleaning manually, you wish to
increase the frequency and have it remain constantly empty and clean, but that's
up to you.

Good question regarding the granules. What I've found is that
some granules stick to the poop and get flushed, and some get scattered when the
cat jumps out. It's about the same as regular litter for scatter-rate but
because you won't need to tend to the box very often you may find yourself
visiting after a week or two to find a bunch scattered. My solution is to just
sweep them up and back into the box, but over time you may need to add more.
This is just my experience, but I'd say that you would add about 1/5 of the box
every couple months - So about a box per year. We only have one cat though, so
your scatter rates may differ. ;)

I think the dome would help quite a bit if
your cat likes enclosed spaces.
April   |2009-06-09 11:26:07
Alex, you can just set the CatGenie on a timer and it will clean as many times
as you want up to 4 times a day
Mary  - The Litter Robot   |2009-06-19 09:19:46
Mike,

I had the litter robot about 2 1/2 month and my cat is a maincoon cat so
he is too big, does not feed in the little robot. I loved the machine but it's
really good idea for a small type of cat. I have to return it because my cat
never ever wanted to poo in the unit. My advice if you have a big cat don't buy
it.
Barb  - New Litterbox   |2008-07-12 20:26:13
I think before the final decision is made on the best litterbox available;
everyone should check out the LitterHouse. Google it!
Peter   |2008-07-13 14:23:34
It's cute, but it doesn't solve any of the core issues of still having to clean
and maintain kitty's waste. There also could be potential health issues with
having the fecal matter that close to your living area.

I suppose if you only
had a one-room house or something this would be an option, but I still stand by
my vote for the Cat Genie as best litterbox.
Amanda   |2008-07-20 15:09:07
The Litter House is not an option for those looking for an automatic litter box.
It is simply an overpriced plastic house shaped cover to put over the basic
litter pan.
Amanda   |2008-07-20 15:15:50
Peter,

Thank you for taking the time to talk about this litterbox. I have
been using the Petmate brand "Purrforma" litterbox since November 2006
and it died on me last week. It worked fine for the first 6 months or so but
then I found myself constantly adjusting it, fixing it, and unjamming it. YUCK.
Plus the little bas that collect the litter are expensive and tear easy.

I
am excited to order this box and get it going. My only worry is that I will not
get the water line and waste line hooked up correctly. I may have to enlist
some help from my best friends husband to make sure I am doing it right. I am
not too handy at that kinda stuff.
Peter   |2008-07-21 11:55:11
Amanda,

You won't have a problem with the water line, it's no more difficult
than attaching a garden hose to the outside tap - Same threading on both. These
taps are found in every laundry room which makes it a logical choice, or you may
have one in your basement (where we have ours). The waste line goes into any
drain pipe or into a toilet bowl - Again, the laundry area has a drain already
making it ideal, but basements also have floor drains and I simply cut a hole in
our floor drain cover large enough for a PVC pipe. The Cat Genie drain hose
just rests on the PVC pipe and everything works perfectly.

That being said,
I'm sure your friend's husband would love to help - Us guys can't resist being
involved with high-tech gizmos/robots. ;)
Betty  - Unit Lifetime   |2008-09-12 09:23:54
How long has your unit lasted so far? Also, is anyone using it through their
bathrooms? Another question, if you put it in your washroom can your washer and
this gadget share the same line?????
Peter   |2008-09-12 09:51:09
Hi Betty,

We've had ours for a year now. Haven't tried it in the bathroom,
but others have reported success placing the drain under the toilet seat (the
hose is naturally squared off at the top for this.)

The Cat Genie comes with
a Y-type adaptor so it can be connected to your water line at the same time as
your washer.

Hope that helps.
ceseme  - Pellets and Diarreah   |2008-10-11 11:22:13
If it is true that the granules are permanent and reusable, why then are they
selling replacement pellets? How often is it necessary to replenish the
pellets? Do they get tracked out of the genie like ordinary litter?

Also, if a
cat's poop is very soft, will it get left behind or stick to the rake during the
cleaning cycle and therefore not get clean and cause a stink during the blow dry
phase as some have commented?
Peter   |2008-10-11 12:51:15
The granules are permanent, however as mentioned they do get tracked out of the
litter box (high sidewalls and/or dome help dramatically with this). We have
the high side walls and replenish ours every 5-6 months with about 1/2 box.
Sweeping up the scatter back into the box helps as well.

If the poop is soft,
it could potentially fall through the rake (just as it could when scooping
manually) so it's advised in the manual that you watch for the time of day that
your cat does his business and then wait a few hours for poop to harden before
running the cycle. The cycles will run at the same times each day and cats keep
a fairly regular pattern so once you've set it, generally things will run
smoothly.
Shelley  - big enough for 14lb cat?   |2008-11-13 12:30:19
I've got 2 larger cats, at 12 and 14 pounds. They are used to a domed litter
box but I use an XL size. Is the CatGenie with dome big enough for a larger
cat?
Thanks,
Shelley
Carol  - Let us know about large cats!   |2008-11-25 21:40:05
On another post about Cat Genie, someone said they had two Shaq-sized cats and
it worked fine, but they did not mention whether or not they had the dome.

I
too would like to know about this, as my boys are 16 lb and 19 1/2 lb. They
liked the Cat Cabana on the Littermaid but would sit on top so it broke the
supports. I haven't spent $45 on a replacement.
gayle  - Also would like to know about big kitties!   |2008-12-03 08:55:11
My two boys are about 16 pounds each; I am also concerned about whether or not
they will "fit" in it. They use a jumbo size regular litter box and do
not use cover (no shame). Anyone?
Peter   |2008-12-04 16:42:07
Hopefully this helps you Shelly, Carol and Gayle...I just weighed our big
fella and he's 15 pounds, he's been using it for over a year now - you
can view pictures of how he looks/fits in the CatGenie in the photos
section: http://www.liveautomatic.com/photos/35-personal...

Cheers,
Peter
Aaron  - Cheap alternative: toilet training   |2009-02-19 06:51:15
Nice article! And most cool gadget! :)

Still, it seems worth mentioning that
it is also possible to train a cat to share its humans toilet.

+ MUCH
cheaper
+ saves the space of a designated cat toilet

- training effort
-
either you put up with the feline floaters until you come around to flushing for
your kitty (although the cat might notify you after having gone to the toilet)
or you try teaching it to flush, but run a great risk that it will discover the
fun of flushing with no end, thus raising the water bill
Cat Luvr  - Just a thought   |2009-02-26 18:56:17
While this machine will partly pay for itself and solve this problem I came up
with a better solution.

Feeding my cats was another major factor in kitten
costs, which in turn was costing me more in pooping costs.

I stopped feeding my
cats and I started instantly saving on food. Within a few days they stopped
pooping and from here on it will be golden.

The meowing was keeping me up for
the first week, but now it's slowed. The one cat has been pouting in his bed
for 2 days now, he won't even move - LOL
annonymous  - re:just a thought   |2009-06-23 08:25:50
someone who stops feeding their cat probably shouldn't be called cat luvr
Carl   |2009-03-11 07:28:04
OK, I bought this thing because my wife though it was the best thing since
sliced bread, and I hate to say it but she was right, again,this time. At first
our two young korat cats were scared to death of the thing and after two months
they love to sit and watch the thing work. Now, after it has finished it's
cleaning the two cats like to lay in the thing because it's so nice and clean
and warm after the dry cycle. I have to say most things like this are a pain to
setup and operate but this thing is so easy, and does just what it is supposed
to do. If your thinking about getting one, go ahead, I don't think you will
regret it.
Sharon G   |2009-03-12 21:23:10
I just purchased the Cat Genie. My cats started using it after 3 days. When I
ran the first clean cycle, the hand did not scoop any of the waste. The hand is
firmly attached per the instructions and does not appear to have a problem. I
am currently running another cycle. If results are the same, I will contact the
company. Have any of you had this problem? Do you have any suggestions?
elle   |2009-03-14 00:15:29
I think some of these comments are clearly written by marketers of the cat
genie. Cat poo is completely compostable. There are no health risks to having
cats poo in your garden, your composter, or whatever.
It jsut seems some
friendly posters are awfully concerned about addressing all of the questionsof
potential buyers.
Peter   |2009-03-14 14:34:19
Elle, I think the comment you made is at best dangerous and needs qualification
and at worst plainly misleading. Composting cat poo requires a separate
composter, special care and even after all that it can never be used in gardens
where anything is consumed (ie. vegetable or fruit gardens).
Regarding the
posters and their questions, many responses have been from me as I am passionate
about the cat genie (and any devices that save me work) but other readers here
have expressed their pleasure (and displeasure) of the genie and other litter
boxes. When a technology helps people have a little more free time in their
lives, people get excited - after all, you took the time to post, why wouldn't
others?
Peter   |2009-03-14 14:37:40
The only thing I can suggest is to pull the main unit (the big square part with
the buttons) off for a brief moment, reset the arm into it's most upright
position and then put the main unit back down and run the cycle again. If this
doesn't work I would definitely give the company a call, they're pretty well
versed in the various issues and solutions.
lars  - A few thoughts   |2009-04-01 02:29:12
As far as I can determine it looks like the Cat Genie is a good purchase. A few
thoughts however is I see that Peter is very warm spoken about this device.
Would like to have some more feedback from other people as well. My question is
if I attache it to the laundry room and the outlet for the wastewater is taken
by the washer and I don't have a second outlet how would I get the wasteline
from Cat Genie to fit there? Any suggestions?
April   |2009-06-15 12:52:23
Lars, when you purchase the cat genie it comes with a Y shaped adapter, so you
can use both your washer and the cat genie
Carla Whaley  - 4 cat genies   |2009-04-22 19:02:08
Well, I have 4 cat genies so you would have 2 figure I like them a lot. NOT. Out
of the 4 only 1 is presently working. They all worked for about 6 months great,
then it was 1 thing, then another. Calls to the company. In all fairness the
company is very good at replying and replacing broken parts mostly for free.
Problem was i spent more time fixing them than they spent cleaning. I have 3 set
up with 2 t joints in my laundry and no that is not the problem. Revolving kept
getting stuck, did not suck liquid out, litter hand went bad, 2 processors went
bad--all fixed and more and very friendly but I would not get 1 fixed before
another had a problem. Right now I have a couple boxes of repair parts to open
but i have given up. The processors were sent 2 me (2 broken) and the return was
free but then you have to take off water part which is a pain. I actually have
no problem with the cost--sweep up the granuels but i am a nurse and sort of
like things clean---works great when not broken. I liked that i could run it
several times and also push run whenever i wanted to--whenever i saw cat use it.
And when it works, I love it. I have 4 grown cats and right now 4 kittens--I
have a cattery, Bare4me and Itsasphynx--and breed no hair sphynx cats. If the
cat has loose stools as mine often do, sometimes you can't really stay in the
house--hot drying poop really smells. But even that didn't deter me. It really
is clean. Anyway, right now I am using a large regular box, have 2 broken and 1
working cat genie (which cats mostly don't use--they prefer regular litter but i
didn't give them a choice for awhile and had no problem with using the cat
genie)--looking for an automatic cat cleaner that keeps on ticking. I live in
tampa florida, so anyone nearby that would like a cat genie for free, e-mail me.
I don't have time to mail them or fix them. Service from cat genie is great.
Rachel  - A blessing.... When it works   |2009-05-24 10:47:30
You said it perfectly. I love the Catgenie when it works..... which isn\'t that often. If you had asked me the first 3 months,
I would have told you how in love with it I was. Now I keep hoping
I can go a week without the sounds of little beeps ringing through the
house.

I have to say that I think the Catgenie is best for those
who don\'t mind the frequent sound of error beeps and who enjoy
constantly tinkering with mechanical equipment - much like those people who
keep clunkers in their garage so they can always be working on it. I,
on the other hand, detest the nasty, smelly work of always having to take
apart the Catgenie and mess in poopie water to figure out why it
isn\'t working this time around. I had to beg my 80 year old mother
not to get one for herself and her several cats as I know there is
absolutely no chance she will be calling customer service every few days or
will have the patience or know-how to take one apart once a week. I
could picture her in tears when it falls apart - which is more regular than
a full moon.  

As soon as I have the money, the Catgenie will be
toast and I will have a Litter Robot. It seems most of the reviews I have
read for it are from former Catgenie owners.
Kim  - Free Cat Genie   |2009-06-02 11:30:05
I just read your review of Cat Genie.

The free box you are referring too, is
that the one that works? Or all of them, parts too?

I am definitely
interested.

Please write me back!
Craigk  - a few probs   |2009-06-17 19:28:38
We have been using the Cat Genie for about a year for my big boy (about 18
healthy pounds). He is prone to UTI's and I figured this would be great. All
in all, it works pretty good for Bubby, though my roommate and i have to do some
extra chores.

The arm tends to land right smack dab on top of Bubby's poos (he
eats a raw diet and his potties are harder than what most folks are used to)
squishing them and making a big mess. ever smell cooked cat poo, its not
pleasant. We have resorted to scooping the poo before running the cycle. Yeah
its a pain, but since his don't smell (a great effect of the raw diet) its not
too bad.

The pellets go everywhere, and I mean everywhere. We find them all
over the place and they are not fun to step on when exiting the shower. Bubby
does not care about scratching too much, so we have just let the level drop down
to maybe a quarter of a box.

No UTI's for a year now, perhaps due to the Genie,
or his diet, or both.
CatLady  - Litter   |2009-06-23 08:33:03
Craigk,

Have you tried the dome or the GeniePaws, they can help reduce the
amount of litter that does get scattered. I have read a lot of reviews where
people sweep up the litter they find or shake out the geniepaws back into the
CatGenie so they are not wasting the granules.
CraigK  - litter   |2009-06-23 11:14:01
He is way too big for the dome, and themat might work except he avoids stuff
like that and he likes to scratch all over the darn place. He will scratch the
litter, the floor, the side of the machine, the door, takes him 5 minutes to
"flush". I am too bugged out by the pellets, except at 2am on barefeet

3.23 Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

Last Updated on Monday, 13 April 2009 19:26